Indoor Golf vs Outdoor Golf: Course Comparison-Coeur D’Alene Golf Course 

In recent years, golf simulators have become increasingly popular, providing golfers with a convenient and engaging way to practice and play the game year-round. The high-tech systems like the ones we use here at OGP, incorporate advanced tracking sensors and detailed 3D course recreations to offer an immersive golf experience indoors.

outdoor-golf-course-comparison-to-indoor-golf-course
https://www.cdaresort.com/golf-course/

While golf simulators undoubtedly offer numerous benefits, such as instant feedback, weather-independent play, and the ability to sample courses from around the world, the question remains – how does the simulator experience compare to playing on an actual golf course? I have you covered. As a recently graduated collegiate golfer, I had the opportunity to play a number of beautiful courses in the United States-many of which are playable on our simulator. There is one course in particular that I had the pleasure of playing a number of times-enough times that I can confidently say I can sufficiently compare the simulator version to the real deal. This course is Coeur D’Alene Golf Course, located in Coeur D’Alene, Idaho. The stunning course is, in my opinion, a must play. It is far away though, so for now, let me tell you how close you can get to playing the real thing from right here at OGP.

In this blog post, we’ll take a deep dive into the simulator vs. reality comparison hole-by-hole, looking at just how accurate our technology is in comparison to the IRL golf course. I used one of my old yardage books to compare, and I promise to be as honest as possible!

Let’s begin.

Hole-By-Hole

The first hole is a dog-leg right, and as the hole-by hole on the website states, the fairway is forgiving, and for those looking to go for the green in two, a right center tee shot is preferred to take the trees on the left out of play. A lay up left is a safe play, but the green is reachable, both in real life and on the simulator. From what I recall, there is a somewhat steep slope down off the right side of the green, which isn’t as visible or in play on the simulator (this makes it easier to score here though). The slopes of the green are accurate to the green book.

Hole 2 is a test to say the least. It is definitely easier to play on the simulator in comparison to the real thing, where the long, slight dog-leg right par 4 demands accuracy in order to be set up for a good second shot. Yesterday I hit my drive slightly left, and while I would’ve been struggling on my approach in real life, I was easily able to hit it from the rough on the sim. The slight false front is less pronounced digitally, but definitely still comes into play, and the big green slopes fairly accurately.

The third hole is a slightly daunting one to look at, both in person and on the simulator, and from what I can remember, it plays almost exactly the same in both circumstances. Aiming right allows the ball to kick well off the slope and roll close to the hole. The biggest simulator benefit here in my opinion, is the fact that you don’t need to hike up the humongous hill after you finish out the hole.

Hole 4 again, plays almost exactly the same as it does in real life. You have to lay-up off the tee into a good position in order to be able to attack the pin. The approach is said to play 6-7 yards up in my book and on the sim alike-so if you’re worried about slope accuracy indoors, don’t be.

Hole 5 and 6 are both par threes-and extremely interesting ones at that. One thing I will say about these two holes is that you do need to see them, and the sim doesn’t quite give you the same view as what you would have in person. Hole 5 is home to a clover-shaped, three-tiered green that is surrounded by one of the world’s largest bunkers, and a number of rust-toned rock outcroppings. Each prong of the green is very narrow. In real life, aiming at the middle every single time is the right play, but on the sim it seems much less daunting to fire one right at the pin. I guess it helps that you’re automatically lined up straight! The tiers in the green definitely come into play as they would in real life, so keep that in mind.

Hole 6 plays extremely downhill-18 yards down on the sim, and 20 yards down in my yardage book. The ball rolls a fair amount off the back in both cases. There are steep slopes on the left and the right and they do come into play in both the digital and real versions of the golf course.

Holes 7 is pretty straightforward, the bunkers are less in play on the digital version, but the overall look of the hole is set up really nicely and very similar to the real thing. Same with hole 8. There is a tree in the middle of the fairway that comes into play as much as it would in real life. I’ve hit straight into it in both cases, and trust me, the ball bounces off those branches the same way.

Hole 9, 10, 11, and 12, are fairly straightforward and similar to the real deal-maybe a touch easier to play. 13 is an interesting one. Depending on tees you can go for the green off the tee, but honestly, I think this hole plays harder on the simulator than it does in real life. The sim makes the water off the left seem more daunting than it is, and for some reason it’s just tricky to hit a straight tee shot. Wind also comes into play digitally, but because you can’t feel it, it’s tricky to remember to take it into account-beware of this when you play any sim courses!

14 is the course’s signature hole. One of only two island greens to exist, this one is a sight to see. Though you get a good look digitally, you don’t get to take the boat up to the green as you do in real life. In terms of golf alone though, the hole plays accurately.

15 is a short par 5, easy to reach but hard to putt on since the green is about 35 yards long, and narrow. The drive and approach shots are accurate, and the greenside bunkers prove a challenge. 16 is a classic hole, not much to it.

17 plays very different in real life to the simulator. It is extremely short, and very drivable off the tee on the simulator. In real life there is a thick tree line on both sides that make accuracy very necessary. These are not present in the digital version, making it easy to just bomb one down there.

Last but not least, the 18th hole. This one is a bunker-filled challenge both digitally and in real life. The simulator pin placement is placed far back in the corner of the green, making it really difficult to approach the hole. The green is sloped and this is reflected, and the giant bunker is very hard to hit out of despite not having real sand on the mats.

So, Indoor or Outdoor?

There is no right answer to this question-both have benefits and drawbacks. Overall, the simulator tends to downplay the severity of certain hazards like deep bunkers, steep slopes, and dramatic elevation changes that are more pronounced on the actual golf course. So holes with these types of features see the biggest differences between the virtual and real-world experience. Courses like this one are played much for the untouchable experiences they provide, but honestly, if you’re just looking to see an accurate depiction of a course and play some golf without the constraints of travel, time and weather, then it’s perfect! I will admit, it is also much easier to score indoors because you don’t have to hit out of funky lies like bunkers or thick rough.

Generally, I highly recommend coming down to play some courses on our simulators. Chambers Bay, Pebble Beach and Torrey Pines are a few others I’ve played in real life and on the sim, and it’s lovely to see the comparisons and even just to “see the course” on the screen. We have an awesome selection here at OGP-so seriously, come and try them out!

Call or WhatsApp us to book a bay now!

 

Physical Movement in Golf – The Hips

 

Golfers have recognized the importance of physical fitness and strength training for golf performance for several decades, though the emphasis on it has increased over time:

  • In the 1950s-1960s, some pioneering professional golfers like Sam Snead, Ben Hogan, and Arnold Palmer started incorporating basic strength training into their routines, but it was not yet a widespread practice among golfers.
  • In the 1980s and 1990s, a number of top players like Greg Norman, Nick Faldo, and Vijay Singh began to place a greater emphasis on developing strength, power, and physical conditioning as part of their training regimens. This shift was driven in part by the increasing athleticism of players on the PGA Tour.
  • In the 2000s and 2010s, the fitness and training focus for elite golfers really accelerated. Players like Tiger Woods, Rory McIlroy, Dustin Johnson and others made strength training, conditioning, and overall physical preparation a major priority in their games.

Today, comprehensive strength and conditioning programs are considered essential for top professional golfers to maximize performance in terms of increasing swing speed, power, injury prevention, and overall athletic capabilities. This emphasis on fitness has filtered down from the pro ranks to benefit amateur golfers as well. With the rapid development of sports science and technology, coaches across many sports, including golf, have started to analyze player movement and incorporate training in multiple planes of motion based on a deeper understanding of human anatomy and biomechanics. This has helped refine golf-specific strength and conditioning to further optimize performance.

In the past, golf was sometimes viewed as a sport that only required training in the transverse plane. However, the deficiency of comprehensive golf-specific movement training knowledge and limited access to appropriate training facilities had been barriers to the sport’s development in some regions. Addressing these gaps has allowed golfers at all levels to gain access to and benefit from a more holistic approach to golf learning. 

Moving up from the ground, every joint in the body from the ankle, knees, hips, lumbar spine, thoracic spine, shoulders, elbows and wrists have a purpose in 3 planes of motions that create the 3D motion of Golf. Today, one of our S&C specialists, Tim will walk us through how the movement, or lack of movement in the hips can affect our back swing.

Our Hip’s 3 Planes of Movement in the Back Swing

Golfing, like many sports, involves movement across all three fundamental planes of motion:

  1. Frontal plane (lateral/side-to-side movements)
  2. Transverse plane (rotational movements)
  3. Sagittal plane (forward/backward/vertical movements)

During the golf backswing, the body utilizes movements in each of these planes to effectively prepare for the downswing; 

  1. In the frontal plane, the body shifts weight/pressure to the trail (right) side for a right-handed golfer.
  2. In the transverse plane, the body coils by rotating away from the target.
  3. In the sagittal plane, the body creates vertical lift and extension to load the kinetic chain.Correct Golf Swing

These coordinated multi-planar movements generate significant potential energy that can then be efficiently released and transferred into club head speed and ball striking during the downswing. However, limitations in one plane of motion can create compensations or inefficiencies in another, ultimately leading to a loss of power and efficiency, decreased directional control, or inconsistent ball striking.

Understanding how our body moves is crucial for developing an efficient golf swing. Addressing any restrictions or imbalances in fundamental movement patterns, such as within the hips, can help golfers unlock their full athletic potential. Today, we will take a closer look at the role of the hips and how their movement in each plane contributes to an efficient golf swing.

The Crucial Hip Movements in the Transverse Plane

One of the most important and observable hip movements in the golf swing occurs in the transverse (rotational) plane. The hips play a critical role in power generation and control through their internal and external rotation.

During the Backswing:

  • The left hip externally rotates
  • The right hip internally rotates

This asymmetrical hip rotation pattern is essential for creating the coiled, loaded position at the top of the backswing. It allows the shoulders to turn farther away from the target, generating significant potential energy, similar to drawing back the string of a bow in archery. Just as an archer needs full draw to maximize arrow velocity, golfers require adequate hip rotation range of motion to achieve a deep, loaded backswing position. Inadequate hip rotation limits the potential power and consistency that can be transferred into the ball. Focusing on turning the hips more fully in the backswing, while maintaining a stable spine angle, can help remedy issues with power loss and ball striking inconsistency. Optimizing hip mobility and control in the transverse plane is a key component of an efficient golf swing.

Let’s assume our Hips can move well side-to-side (Frontal), and in the verticals (Sagittal), but not rotationally.  A lack of rotation in the hips can cause a number of issues, the most common being:

  • The Sway, including pressure being shifted to the outside of the trail foot, leading to issues with timing to re-centre, or a slide later in the swing to control the low-point
  • Losing structure and width in an attempt to create a bigger back swing.

Hips in the Frontal Plane: Lateral Shift and Tilt

In addition to the critical rotational movements in the transverse plane, the hips play a crucial role in the frontal (lateral) plane during the golf swing. Proper hip abduction and adduction help facilitate the essential weight/pressure shift and maintain balance.

During the Backswing:

  • There is a small amount of lateral shift of the hips towards the trail (right) side.
  • The hips also tilt slightly, with the right hip moving up and the left hip moving down.

As we turn in the backswing, our hips rotate as we shift to create the visual image of a trail hip that does not move away from the target. This controlled lateral weight transfer and hip tilt sets up the proper weight shift back to the lead (left) side on the downswing. The hip tilt helps the golfer maintain spine angle and balance throughout the swing, and sets up the proper angles to land on the lead side on the downswing. Adequate frontal plane hip mobility and control are essential for an efficient, repeatable golf swing. Restrictions in these movements can lead to compensations that negatively impact power transfer, ball control, and overall consistency.

Let’s assume our Hips can rotate well (Transverse), and move well in the verticals (Sagittal). A lack of lateral movement or tilt can cause a number of issues, the most common being:

  • Inability to load the trail slide in the backswing to land left and explode up for the release of speed.
  • We may attempt to create lateral by shifting our torso away from the target, again compromising our ability to control the low point for optimal contact.

Harnessing Hip Extension and Flexion for Power and Stability

While the transverse and frontal plane hip movements are critical, the hips’ sagittal plane actions are also essential for a stable, efficient golf swing.Proper hip flexion and extension help the golfer maintain an optimal posture and center of mass throughout the swing, preventing excessive swaying or lateral movement.

During the Backswing:

  • The trail hips remain flexed;
  • And the lead hip extends to allow for the proper tilts, lateral shifts and rotation to match-up.

This movement is also crucial for preparing for vertical force. I’d like to invite you to stand up with your feet hip width, and JUMP as high as you can. Without a golf ball, you will notice your natural instincts kick in. You will start with a small lift, land with a bend in your knees and flexion/bend in your hips, followed by a powerful extension of the hips and torso to propel yourself upwards. This same principle applies in the golf swing. In our backswing we are essentially creating lift (this does not mean our head gets higher), to prepare ourselves for the landing to then jump and release speed.

A lack of extension/flexion can cause a number of issues, a few examples being:

  • Attempting to extend through lumbar spine causing lower back pain
  • Excessive arm lift to attempt to create verticals without the use of the body

Extension in golf swing

Head movement in golf swing

Unlock Your Golf Potential by Optimizing Hip Mechanics

By understanding and training these relationships in the hips, golfers can unlock more power, control, and consistency in their ball striking.  By developing a deep understanding of hip movement patterns and their impact on the golf swing, players can make targeted improvements to unlock their full athletic potential on the course. 

A proper, unrestricted golf swing is an important element for staying injury-free, scoring well and/or playing at a high level. When the hips move efficiently through the swing’s phases, it creates optimal separation between the upper body and lower body – the renowned “X-Factor” that allows golfers to effectively transfer energy from the ground, through the body, and into the club.

Restrictions or compensations in hip mobility and control can disrupt this critical kinetic chain, leading to certain inefficiencies including certain swing tendencies, inconsistency, and lost distance.

To assess and address any physical limitations impacting your swing, we recommend booking a Titleist Performance Institute (TPI) assessment with Tim, one of our S&C specialists. During this comprehensive evaluation, our experts will analyze your golf-specific movement patterns, identify areas for improvement, and provide tailored training recommendations.

Come visit us now! 

Written by: Timothy Lau, OGP S&C Specialist

×